| Lori Stark | 1988hm | |||
| Allison Miazga | 1990# | |||
| Tricia Gaudette | 1991^ | |||
| Laura Gentile | 1992# | |||
| Melissa Panasci | 1995^ | 1996^ | ||
| Cyndi Breyer | 1997^ | |||
| Courtney Sommer | 1998^ | 1999# | 2000# | |
| Corey Ceccolini | 1999# | |||
| Angie North | 2001# | |||
| Katie Grant | 2003# | 2005* | ||
| Gracie Sorbello | 2003# | |||
| Nicole Dudek | 2004^ | 2005# | ||
| Hilary Linton | 2004# | 2005* | 2006* | |
| Laura Suchoski | 2005^ | 2006* | 2007* | 2008* |
| Amy Stopford | 2006* | |||
| Marian Dickinson | 2006^ | 2007# | 2008^ | |
| Caitlin Williams | 2007# | |||
| Lauren Miller | 2007^ | 2008* | 2009* | |
| Amie Survilla | 2009* | |||
| Rhian Jones | 2009^ | 2010# | 2011# | |
| Stefanie Fee | 2011# | |||
| Emmie Le Marchand | 2011^ | |||
| Samantha Nelson | 2011^ | |||
| Paula Heimbach | 2012^ |
* - First Team; # - Second Team; ^ - Third Team; hm - Honorable Mention
