| Dick Dion | 1961hm | ||
| George Smith | 1962^ | ||
| Bill Mallon | 1972hm | 1973hm | |
| Charlie Bolling | 1981# | ||
| Chuck Taylor | 1984^ | 1985# | |
| John Karcher | 1990^ | ||
| Jason Widener | 1990# | ||
| Joe Ogilvie | 1995hm | ||
| Jason Buha | 1997# | ||
| Matt Krauss | 1999hm | 2000hm | |
| Nathan Smith | 2004^ | 2005hm | |
| Ryan Blaum | 2004hm | 2005* | 2006# |
| Michael Schachner | 2005hm | 2007hm | |
| Jake Grodzinsky | 2006hm | ||
| Brinson Paolini |
2011hm | ||
| Julian Suri |
2012^ and hm |
* - First Team; # - Second Team; ^ - Third Team; hm - Honorable Mention
