| Tricia Martin | 1998* | 1999* | 2000# | |
| Kate Kaiser | 1999# | 2000* | 2001* | 2003* |
| Kate Soulier | 1999^ | |||
| Meghan Walters | 2000^ | 2001# | 2004# | |
| Kristen Foster | 2001* | 2002# | ||
| Lauren Gallagher | 2001* | 2002* | 2003^ | |
| Meghan Miller | 2003# | 2004# | ||
| Katie Chrest | 2004^ | 2005* | 2006* | |
| Megan Huether | 2005* | |||
| Caline McHenry | 2005* | |||
| Rachel Sanford | 2005# | 2006* | 2007^ | |
| Laura Anderson | 2006# | |||
| Leigh Jester | 2006# | 2007^ | ||
| Kristen Waagbo | 2006^ | 2007* | ||
| Caroline Cryer | 2007* | 2009* | ||
| Carolyn Davis | 2007^ | 2008* | 2009* | |
| Megan Del Monte | 2008^ | |||
| Emma Hamm | 2008^ | 2011* | 2012^ | |
| Aiyana Newton | 2008* | |||
| Sarah Bullard | 2009# | 2010* | ||
| Lindsay Gilbride | 2009^ | 2010# | ||
| Danielle Kachulis | 2010^ | |||
| Christie Kaestner | 2011* | |||
| Kat Thomas | 2011# | |||
| Kim Wenger | 2011# | 2012# | ||
| Taylor Virden | 2013* | |||
| Kelsey Duryea | 2013# |
* - First Team; # - Second Team; ^ - Third Team
