| Ashley Wacholder | 1993^ | 1994^ | ||
| Ali Hausfeld | 2004hm | 2005hm | 2006hm | 2007hm |
| Stephanie Istvan | 2004hm | |||
| Carrie DeMange | 2005hm | 2006hm | 2007hm | |
| Jenny Shull | 2005hm | |||
| Tealle Hunkus | 2006hm | |||
| Rachael Moss | 2007hm | 2008hm | 2009hm | |
| Jourdan Norman | 2008hm | |||
| Kellie Catanach | 2009hm | 2010^ | 2011hm | |
| Becci Burling |
2010hm | |||
| Christiana Gray | 2010hm | 2011hm | ||
| Amanda Robertson |
2010hm | |||
| Ali McCurdy | 2010hm | 2011hm | 2012hm |
^ - Third Team • hm - Honorable Mention
