| Name | Sport | Year |
| Danny Farrar | Boxing - 145 lbs. | 1936 |
| Mat Raymond | Boxing - 175 lbs. | 1936 |
| Mat Raymond | Boxing - 165 lbs. | 1937 |
| Joel Shankle | Men's Track & Field - Outdoor Long Jump | 1955 |
| Bob Wheeler | Men's Track & Field - 1,000 Yards | 1971 |
| Jeremy Kahn | Men's Fencing - Epee | 1996 |
| Vanessa Webb | Women's Tennis | 1998 |
| Candy Hannemann | Women's Golf | 2001 |
| Virada Nirapathpongporn | Women's Golf | 2002 |
| Anna Grzebien | Women's Golf | 2005 |
| Shannon Rowbury | Women's Track & Field - Indoor Mile | 2007 |
| Becca Ward |
Women's Fencing - Saber |
2009 |
| Mallory Cecil | Women's Tennis | 2009 |
| Nick McCrory |
Men's Diving - Platform Diving |
2010 |
| Abby Johnston |
Women's Diving - Three-Meter Springboard |
2011 |
| Nick McCrory |
Men's Diving - Platform Diving |
2011 |
| Becca Ward | Women's Fencing - Saber | 2011 |
| Juliet Bottorff | Women's Track & Field - Outdoor 10K | 2011 |
| Curtis Beach | Men's Track & Field - Indoor Heptathlon | 2012 |
| Becca Ward | Women's Fencing - Saber | 2012 |
| Nick McCrory | Men's Diving - Platform Diving | 2013 |
